Sunday, September 26, 2010

ANARCHY EVOLUTION: FAITH, SCIENCE, AND BAD RELIGION IN A WORLD WITHOUT GOD by Greg Graffin and Steve Olson

It could be said that Greg Graffin shares a lot in common with the fictional character Indiana Jones. Both are professors at universities. Both have a deep desire to study history. Both have battled it out with Nazis — well, okay, maybe not exactly, but Greg did have to deal with the racist skinhead contingent in the LA punk scene in the early ’80s. Nonetheless, the one main bond between the two is a desire to understand the world’s histories through the study of facts and evidence.


Anarchy Evolution explores what is at the root of the inquisitive mind of Dr. Graffin when it comes to the subject of evolutionism versus creationism. The study of evolutionism through the works of people like Charles Darwin fascinated Greg as a child and proved to be a driving force in his life as laid out in this book, and, of course, in the lyrics to Bad Religion’s music.


Anarchy Evolution reads like two books in one. Half of the book is written in an autobiographical sense as Graffin details growing up in Wisconsin, his family, moving out west to LA, and the events leading up to the founding of Bad Religion with Brett Gurewitz. The other half reads like a textbook, with detailed passages that feel like they came right out of his lecture series at UCLA (where he teaches evolution). He ties the personal and educational together by drawing examples of how certain parts of his life (especially his teenage years) echo the natural effects of anarchic evolution — hence the title of the book.
Graffin challenges almost every aspect of religious rule in this book, well beyond evolution. He challenges the claim of an eternal afterlife and spends a good deal of time talking about the falsehood of natural selection. He also tackles the issue of being an atheist. Graffin himself doesn’t really consider himself a so-called atheist, but really a “naturalist” — as in someone who believes solely that no supernatural entities were or are involved in creating what we know as the universe. His naturalist worldview is based upon “observation, experiment, and verification.” He spends a good deal of time in this book detailing many of his adventures observing nature and gathering evidence in collegiate field studies, including an amazing story about a trip to the Amazon while working at the Los Angeles County Museum of Natural History in 1987. This trip would change Greg’s life forever.

Much of Anarchy Evolution could be considered adequate reading material for an introduction into the history of evolutionary biology. After all, this was written by someone who teaches this material to students at UCLA. So some of this material might be already common knowledge, depending on your educational background. If you’re not up on the subject of evolutionary biology, don’t be surprised if you have to re-read passages as some of this information is quite deep in facts, names, and dates. Luckily, there are nearly 50 pages of cited notes in the back of the book.

For the Bad Religion fans out there, this book will also please your need for random stories about people and places involved in the creation of the band and the making of some of your favorite albums. So while you’re learning about why Greg Graffin was arrested in high school, you’ll also be learning about a certain type of ant that lives in the forests of central Mexico.


Anarchy Evolution is clearly a work of love by a man that loves his work. His views on religion don’t aim to offend, but rather to question the religious status quo. He simply refuses to believe in something that he can’t observe or investigate, as it goes against his naturalist worldview. He studied the evidence and came to the conclusion that there is no supernatural being issuing a hand of assistance (or dominance) in creating the world and universe as we know it today, tomorrow, and in the distant past. He invites you to question the answers and make up your own mind by doing your own investigating and observing. A very insightful and interesting read.

No comments:

Post a Comment